The
Fight Club strategies we have learned throughout the semester are crucial in
developing our papers. We have learned many techniques from formatting our arguments,
addressing counterarguments, to communicating our positions in effective
mannerism by using paradigms and concepts from “They Say, I Say”. We can use
these techniques in our papers, as we must find ways to argue our proposal
despite opposing viewpoints.
Many times in Fight Club,
we must argue something that we may disagree upon. I believe this will help us
tremendously when finalizing our papers because we have learned how to play the
devil’s advocate in most situations. Thus, we are able to address many counter
arguments as they arise in our papers, therefore strengthening our proposals and
allowing us to connect with the audience. However, Fight Club does not address
formal writing strategies as well as it prepares us for voicing our opinions
and anticipating counters. In Fight Club, one is preoccupied with ideas and
counter parts instead of focusing on the conventional details that need to be
present in papers that we turn in. In addition, in a verbal environment we are
able to express our specific points clearly and explicitly, which can prove to
be difficult in writing. However, through the paradigms and templates we have
learned, I believe our proposals will be much stronger as we learn how to address
counters, popular opinions, or our own viewpoints. Overall, I think Fight Club
has been preparing us in recognizing the counters of our audience in our
proposals, which is crucial in writing a strong proposal.
I agree that fight club made it easier for us to address counterarguments. I'm sure that is a skill that improved at least a little for most people in this class. Another skill you mentioned is being able to argue something you are against. Although this is hard, it is possible and fight club helped us develop the skills to do it.
ReplyDeleteAlthough fighting for opposing views improves our argumentative skills and requires higher detail, why do you find that a formal forum cannot be used? When participating in Fight Club I myself do so. Do you believe the formality is inappropriate for the classroom setting it that it's just not used?
ReplyDeleteI agree with the point you made about having to play devil's advocate in Fight Club. That is going to make it easier for us to respond to and realize criticisms of our own papers when we are finalizing them.
ReplyDeleteI agree with both Anna and Abigail. We are randomly assigned a side in fight club and have to fight for that side. I have already been able to tell this is helpful with addressing the counterarguments.
ReplyDelete