Overall this research paper has been more of a chore than
learning experience for me. It didn’t do much that in class fight clubs, or
other assignments didn’t. Learning to properly construct an argument and do research
for that argument is important, but I feel like I spent more time just trying
to meet the requirements than actually thinking about what I was doing. If I
were to do something like this again I would prefer to just have some subject
assigned to write about. Having to come up with one myself led to me wasting a
lot of time trying to arbitrarily choose one. Having a specific one assigned
could have also removed the home-town focus, which I did not find very helpful
or useful. Knowing what audience you are writing for is important, but this particular
audience just added difficulty instead of direction as there is not anything
particularly special about my hometown for me to incorporate. Additionally,
although annotated bibliographies can be useful, I would prefer it if
annotations were not required as most of the time when I was searching my
sources for material to use I just went to the actual source anyway. I also
think the length requirements for each individual annotation were a bit
excessive. The in class essay was
probably the most useful thing we did because it gave us a chance to practice
just the basic skill of constructing an argument without many of the
distractions that come into play with other assignments. So overall the process
of writing this paper may have slightly improved my writing, but not
drastically. As for Strunk and White, there were plenty of other resources
available for reference and I found them to be more helpful.
I like that you brought up critiques of the writing process in this post. But, I disagree that the topics should be assigned. For my project, I have been more engaged in it than I would be if I was given a topic. To help future students doing this assignment, it should be emphasized that the topics chosen should be of interest to the writer or else the paper will be a chore, as you said. Also, the writing will be better if the student genuinely cares about his or her proposal.
ReplyDelete