In Taylor Swift's Bad Blood song, her tone of voice and volume when singing are far more aggressive than the cover version by Ryan Adams. Adams take a far more relaxed approach on Bad Blood. Rhetorically analyzing these two songs that have the exact same lyrics is interesting because they really do give off completely different vibes.
Delving deeper into the differences, listeners hear in the line "it's so sad to, think about the good times, you and I..." in Adam's version and feel reminiscent and maybe even sorrowful. However, when you hear that exact same line by Taylor Swift, she sounds aggressive, angry and vengeful. In this case, the message from the songs are completely different. Adam's Bad Blood video's message is reflective of the relationship these two had and how he is filled with sadness as it seems like it's coming to an end, "did you think we'd be fine?" The message is conveyed effectively because you can hear in his tone the emotional distress he feels post this relationship. The slower pace of the song and the gentle guitar strums effectively convey the message of hurting as well.
In contrast, Taylor Swift's Bad Blood line ""it's so sad to, think about the good times, you and I..." sounds angry and ready to move on. As the music builds and the song drops, Swift does not sound like the damsel in distress, she sounds confident. She sounds angry but like she's over it and moving on. Therefore, Swift effectively conveys her message of confidence and female strength through her voice.
Not only did the tone of voice by the singer matter, but the way the music went along with the lyrics was critical in interpreting the message. While the lyrics remained the same, Swift and Adam's song had completely different messages that were conveyed effectively. Swifts being, confidence and female strength when a relationship ends. While Adam's message was more along the lines of the typical sorrowful breakup and how he doesn't want it to end.
Which version is more effective? Do you think Swift's version was more effective because she is the author, or do you think the cover meshes better with the lyrics?
ReplyDeleteYou did a great job of describing the emotions that the lyrics evoke in each song. It is interesting how the singer's tone can completely change the meaning of the words. Also, you structured your analysis well by first addressing specific lyrics and then discussing the music. I agree that Adams is sorrowful while Swift seems confident.
ReplyDeleteYou did a great job, i took a very similar approach. Comparing the two songs was definitely very interesting to read about and also do. Did you think they were both equally good songs? Which is more your style?
ReplyDelete