When comparing these two songs, a huge difference stands out
between them, which is their tone. We all know, and if you didn’t, that Taylor
Swift’s song is directed towards her “beef” with fellow Pop star Katy Perry. In
this context, the song is most nearly about Taylor’s upset feelings towards
Katy Perry. If so, then the song pacts a tone that is hateful and spiteful, as
if it gives off a chant that is yelled before battle. In more depth on the
aspect of a battle, the whole music shows Taylor prepping a team to take on her
arch nemesis, Arsyn. Thus, proving that Taylor Swift’s version of the song is
made in spite, whereas Ryan Adams’ version seems to address a love aspect. His
tone seems to more about a loved one he has had a falling out with. The song is
more somber than Taylor’s rendition, which shows their difference in tone.
Although
the two share the same lyrics, they differ in what they mean by them. For
example, when the lyrics say “Oh, it’s so sad to think about the good times,
You and I,” (15-16) you can pick up the connotation that Taylor’s good times
are more of a friendship aspect whereas Ryan Adam’s seems to be about some he
dearly loved. In addition, the chorus says, “’Cause baby now we got bad blood,
you know it used to be mad love,” (1-2) which gives off the impression that they once
were deeply connected but due to unfortunate circumstances, a separation occurred
and caused this song to be made. Once again, this lyric gives of the impression
that to Taylor, it’s about an argument, but to Adams, it’s more about the loss
of someone that was close to them.
In conclusion, I believe both Taylor and Adams gave off their message effectively. Swift's message was that she was upset with Katy Perry and is going to get stronger and better in order to fight her, theoretically. Adams message seems to be that he has lost someone dear to him due to a falling out or issue, which is tone gives off effectively.
In conclusion, I believe both Taylor and Adams gave off their message effectively. Swift's message was that she was upset with Katy Perry and is going to get stronger and better in order to fight her, theoretically. Adams message seems to be that he has lost someone dear to him due to a falling out or issue, which is tone gives off effectively.
Martin, Max. (Producer) Bad
Blood [Music Video] Available May 17, 2015, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QcIy9NiNbmo
Adams, Ryan. (Producer) Bad
Blood [Audio Video] Available September 17, 2015, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9V-8VP5dnrQ
I didn't know that Taylor Swift's song was about Katy Perry, so I assumed that it was about a romantic relationship. I interpreted that she is sarcastically singing that "it's so sad to think about the good times," meaning that she is glad to be moving on. Do you think this could also be a valid interpretation of her song?
ReplyDelete